ADA probes MetLife on payment offsets after dentist reports: 7 things to know

Advertisement

The American Dental Association is encouraging dentists who receive a recoupment request, payment offset or overpayment recovery notice from MetLife to ask the insurer for a detailed explanation, citing continued reports from members, according to a Nov. 16 news release from the ADA.

Here are seven things to know:

  1. According to the ADA, MetLife responded that its current policy is not to recover an overpayment made to one provider by offsetting payments owed to an unrelated provider. MetLife characterized the examples the ADA provided as isolated processing errors that were later corrected and said they do not reflect a policy shift.
  2. The ADA’s recommendation follows continued reports of MetLife reducing, or “offsetting,” payments owed to ADA member dentists to recoup overpayments allegedly made to other, unaffiliated dentists.
  3. In April 2025, the ADA sent MetLife a letter after receiving reports of the practice, which occurred when separate dentists treated the same patient or different family members covered under the same policy. The letter questioned the policy in MetLife’s provider agreement that allows the practice and noted that some state laws prohibit it.
  4. In June 2025, MetLife told the ADA by email that it would change its policy “to only offset claim overpayments from the provider [it] overpaid.” The insurer said it was working through the required systems changes and expected them to be done by the end of 2025.
  5. After receiving more reports from dentists who believed their payments had been reduced to recover alleged overpayments involving other offices, the ADA contacted MetLife on Oct. 19, 2026, to ask whether the policy changes had been fully implemented and what the company’s current recovery practices are.
  6. The ADA advises dentists to ask MetLife for the reason for the alleged overpayment, the name of the provider associated with it, the recovery methodology used and information about any related claim adjustments. Because some recovery efforts may involve 6 Degrees Health, dentists can also seek information from that company.
  7. Bertram Hughes, DMD, chair of the ADA Council on Dental Benefit Programs, said the association is monitoring member experiences to determine whether the reports align with the policy MetLife described. He said member reports help the ADA identify patterns and engage with payers, and that the association will continue to advocate for transparent and fair overpayment recovery and assess whether additional action is warranted. 

MetLife did not immediately respond to Becker’s request for comment.

Advertisement

Next Up in Dentists

Advertisement