The barriers keeping new dentists from owning a practice, according to 9 dental leaders

Advertisement

The share of U.S. dentists who own their practice has fallen to its lowest point in two decades — from 85% in 2005 to 73% in 2024, according to a recent report from TUSK Practice Sales. 

Among dentists up to 10 years out of school, more than 25% are now DSO-affiliated, nearly triple the rate of their counterparts with 25 or more years in the field. According to the report, reimbursement rates have risen only 19% since 2021 while inflation has climbed 27%; practice expenses have risen 4.9% over the last five years while practice revenue has grown only 1.4%.

Nine dentists and dental leaders spoke with Becker’s to share what they see as the top barrier to practice ownership and what could help young dentists. There isn’t a universal single fix, but common ideas among dentists included restructuring the path to ownership, reforming dental education and addressing the debt burden.

Note: Responses were lightly edited for clarity and length.

Question: In your view, what is the biggest barrier keeping new dentists from owning a practice, and what would it take to remove that barrier?

Jarred Abel DDS, MD. Oral Surgeon at Bethesda Chevy Chase Oral Surgery and Member of the Doctor Leadership Board at SALT Dental Partners (Phoenix): The biggest barrier keeping new dentists from owning a practice is financial security.  Between student loans with high rates, business loans with high rates, higher overhead costs and potential earlier low income during ramp up months/years in owning a practice, joining a DSO with higher base salary, bonus incentives, and potential equity (in select cases) gives new doctors a sense of more short term financial security. Lower business loan rates, lower overhead costs and more favorable student loans would need to be improved significantly for the landscape to change.

Murat Ayik, DDS. Partner of Specialty1 Partners (Houston): The biggest barrier is risk-adjusted economics, not access to capital. Lenders will finance close to 100% of a practice purchase, but a new grad carrying roughly $300K in student debt would be adding a $700K to $1M practice loan, with an income premium over a salaried job that stays uncertain for the first few years. A DSO offers a strong salary, no administrative burden and no personal guarantee, so for many grads declining ownership is the rational call. The premise also deserves some pushback: plenty of new dentists don’t want to own, and lifestyle and clinical-only preferences drive a real share of DSO affiliation.

What would move it is fixing the risk-reward math rather than waiting on policy. Earn-in tracks with a written valuation formula, meaningful vesting and real governance rights let associates buy equity gradually instead of underwriting a whole practice on day one. Seller financing covering roughly 10-25% of the price, paired with a transition period, gives retiring owners a reason to take slightly less than the top DSO bid and a stake in the handoff working. Neither reverses the DSO trend, since they scale one practice at a time and don’t touch valuation inflation, but together they keep a credible independent path open.

Rocky Dhaliwal, DMD. Dentist and Owner of Redwood Shores Dental Care (Redwood City, Calif.): From my perspective as a practicing dentist and practice owner, the biggest barrier preventing younger dentists from owning their own practices is not simply the financial investment, but the growing complexity and risk of running a dental business. Between student loan debt, rising overhead, staffing challenges, insurance reimbursement pressures, and the cost of technology, many young dentists understandably see employment with a DSO as a safer and more predictable option.

However, I believe we are gradually losing something valuable in dentistry: the independence of the dentist and the personal relationship between the doctor and the patient. Private practice ownership allows dentists to make clinical decisions based on their professional judgment and their patients’ best interests, without the potential pressure of corporate financial targets.

To reverse this trend, we need better access to affordable practice financing, stronger mentorship from experienced practice owners, practical business education in dental schools, and more reasonable reimbursement from insurance companies. We also need to create easier pathways for young dentists to transition into ownership through partnerships and gradual practice acquisitions.

DSOs certainly have a place in dentistry, but I believe independent practices are essential to maintaining a healthy balance in our profession. The goal should not be to discourage corporate dentistry, but to ensure that the next generation of dentists still has a realistic opportunity to become independent owners. Ultimately, dentistry should remain a profession driven by patient care and clinical integrity, not just financial performance.

Benjamin Golik, DDS. Co-founder of URBN Dental (Houston): I believe one of the biggest barriers to practice ownership begins long before a dentist graduates. The rising cost of dental education and the burden of student loan debt place significant financial pressure on young dentists before they even begin their careers. Adding the financial and operational responsibilities of practice ownership can make that next step overwhelming. Making education more affordable and improving access to financing through favorable interest rates and flexible repayment options could make ownership more attainable.

Beyond clinical education, I believe there is an opportunity for dental schools to further emphasize financial literacy, business management, dental insurance and reimbursement, leadership and positive psychology. Developing strong organizational skills, healthy habits and a positive mindset early in one’s career can have a lasting impact on both professional and personal success.

For those of us who have been in the profession for over a decade, we also have a responsibility to help guide the next generation. Whether through residency programs, DSOs or private practices, experienced dentists can share valuable lessons in mental resilience, ergonomics, financial management and navigating the everyday challenges of dentistry.

We should encourage entrepreneurship while recognizing that practice ownership is not the only measure of success. Every dentist should have the opportunity to build a fulfilling and sustainable career without feeling pressured to achieve everything in their first few years.

Dentistry is a marathon, not a sprint. Our ultimate goal is to deliver exceptional patient care, but that begins with a healthy, confident and knowledgeable provider surrounded by a well-supported team. Investing in the next generation of dentists is ultimately an investment in the future of patient care.

David Lam, DDS, MD, PhD. Professor, Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery at the University of Pacific Arthur A. Dugoni School of Dentistry (San Francisco): The greatest barrier to practice ownership for new dentists is an increasingly unfavorable balance between financial risk, professional readiness, and the personal responsibilities associated with running a business.

According to the American Dental Education Association’s 2025 survey of dental school seniors, graduates with educational debt reported an average of $297,800 in total educational debt, including $280,300 attributable specifically to dental school. Combined with the capital required to acquire or establish a practice, rising operating costs, staffing challenges, and increasingly complex administrative demands, this financial burden makes independent ownership a daunting proposition early in a dentist’s career.

However, economics alone does not explain the shift. Work-life balance, predictable schedules, geographic mobility, and personal well-being also influence career decisions. While these preferences are not necessarily unique to younger generations, traditional ownership models can make achieving them more challenging. Choosing employment over ownership should not be interpreted as diminished ambition or professional commitment, but rather as a legitimate career decision.

Dental support organizations have responded to some of these challenges by offering employment models that can reduce immediate financial exposure and administrative responsibilities. Their growth should therefore be viewed not simply as a shift in ownership preferences, but also as a reflection of the financial and operational challenges associated with independent practice.

There is also an important educational responsibility. We have spent decades refining how we teach students to become excellent clinicians. We must now apply the same rigor to preparing them to become successful practice owners. Dental education should incorporate meaningful training in financial literacy, practice management, entrepreneurship, human resources, reimbursement, and leadership, supported by practical mentorship and experiential learning.

Removing these barriers requires more than expanding access to capital. It means creating sustainable pathways to ownership through accessible financing, mentorship, partnerships, shared administrative services, and flexible practice structures that allow dentists to achieve both professional autonomy and personal fulfillment.

Ultimately, the goal should not be to steer graduates toward or away from corporate dentistry. It should be to preserve genuine professional choice. The future of dentistry should be defined by the choices available to young dentists, not by the choices their financial circumstances force them to make.

Shad Lewis, DMD. Dentist at Preventive Dental (Reading, Pa.): The biggest barrier isn’t any single thing. The entire economic model underneath practice ownership has eroded at the same time. Building a new practice costs $900K to $1.7M. Dental school debt is up 587% since 1996. Average GP net income has dropped nearly $60,000 over 16 years when adjusted for inflation. Practice revenue has grown just 1.4% over the past five years while expenses have risen 4.9%. The financing window is closing too. The Fed raised its target rate to 3.75-4% in September, and the SBA’s new underwriting rules require a 1.25x debt service coverage ratio, a 36-month seller note standby, and an independent quality-of-earnings review on deals above $3 million. 

A new dentist does that math and the answer is obvious. Take the associate job and let someone else carry the risk. DSO employment isn’t solving the problem. It’s absorbing the people the economics pushed out of ownership. Student debt delivers new dentists straight to DSOs because those are the only entities that can still make the margins work at scale, and they do it through volume, production quotas, and leverage on supply costs that a solo practice can’t match.  The dentist trades autonomy for a paycheck and the profession slowly consolidates into something that looks more like retail healthcare than independent practice. 

What would it take to reverse it? Honest reimbursement rates that reflect what care actually costs to deliver. Reimbursements have increased 19% since 2021 while inflation has risen 27%. That gap compounds every year. The ADA’s own Health Policy Institute documents this quarterly but describes it in passive voice, as a “squeeze” or “lagging reimbursement,” as if it just happens. It doesn’t just happen. Carriers set those fees, refuse to move them, and brag about healthy margins while dentists absorb the difference. Organized dentistry has watched this erosion for 15 years and treated it like weather instead of policy. Until someone with a platform names the actors and funds the state-level fights on network adequacy and fee transparency, nothing changes.

The barrier to ownership is the ownership model itself. Until that changes, DSO affiliation will keep growing because it’s the rational response to an irrational market.

Barry Lyon, DDS. Pediatric Dentist and Former DSO Executive (Glen Burnie, Md.): I think the barriers preventing graduating dental students from owning a practice are both financial and sociological.

The average dental school debt is $300,000. The estimate for opening, constructing and equipping a three-chair “starter” office with current technology is starting at $450,000. This brings a new grad up to almost a million-dollar commitment before they fill their first tooth. Your average grad would have to think long and hard before agreeing to such an expensive undertaking.

Most of today’s dental school graduates are Generation Z. According to Deloitte’s 2025 Global Gen Z and Millennial Survey, this generation strives for a satisfying work-life balance, with half of those surveyed feeling financially insecure. Only 5% look toward reaching a senior position. This is not a makeup for practice ownership.

From a financial and personal point of view, this generation of dental school graduates is very unlikely to be opening their own practices. An alternative would be joining an independent practice or DSO, gaining experience as a clinician, being mentored on the business aspect of running a practice, and then gradually assuming an ownership position.

Thomas Riley, DMD. Dentist and Owner of Azalea Dental (Summerville, S.C.): The biggest barrier in my opinion is the previous generation of dentists. In order to limit the number of DSOs that are quickly overtaking our profession, we, the practice owners, must look past the quick buck and look at ways to let the next generation of dentists enjoy the profession like we have.  Most selling dentists see the DSO buyout as the best deal, but they cannot see that these corporations are versed in how to get the practice at a value price and how to skim the profits out of the practice. The wise seller would realize that mentoring a new dentist, who can later buy them out or looking for another dentist who wants to take on ownership, can be just as or more lucrative than selling to a DSO. I think this comes from laziness at the end of our career and not planning early enough for our retirement and having a long term strategic plan. I also believe that we have an obligation to fight for this profession and our communities as they have supported us over our careers. The second most important factor is to keep the DSOs out of the dental schools and dental organizations, but that is another discussion.

Robert Trager, DDS. Dentist at John F. Kennedy International Airport (New York City): The younger dentists who have been out of school for 10 to 15 years do not have the managerial and professional skills to buy or open their own practice.

Student debt is also a large factor and the ability to borrow funds to pay for a practice. If the younger graduate is fortunate enough to have a family member or older practitioner who has been a mentor, then they would have the ability to buy a practice or become a partner in a practice. The DSOs act as an oasis and safeguard for the newer practitioners. These new practitioners do not have the responsibilities and business acumen to manage and own their own practice. If these individuals have a long-term goal of owning and operating their own practice, they should take the time to learn the managerial skills to operate a practice in the setting they are in. 

They shouldn’t rely on AI and others to make decisions to prepare for their future ownership. While in their worksite they need to take the time to learn the ins and outs of the dental business which involves managerial and professional skills. Also taking continuing education courses on the latest procedures and techniques in the profession. And possibly find a partner to open a practice that has the same philosophy and background to be successful. 

Advertisement

Next Up in Featured Perspectives

Advertisement